Jrue Holiday vs Jaylen Brown: Who’s the Bigger Star?

The timing of Jrue Holiday’s contract extension, a 4-year/$135 million deal, just before the end of the regular season did come as something of a surprise to many, including The Sports Machine with Slim. With only three games left, one might question whether it would have been more prudent to wait until the season’s conclusion. A valid speculation for this premature extension could be the Celtics’ front office aiming to avoid potential escalated contract demands from Holiday should he deliver an impressive playoff performance.

However, this rationale seems improbable given the team’s abundance of scoring options that may limit Holiday’s opportunities to stand out offensively with substantial numbers. So, what prompted this decision by the Celtics leadership? A plausible explanation could be their intention to thoroughly evaluate Holiday’s work ethic and compatibility with his teammates before committing long-term. Yet, one might argue that such an assessment shouldn’t require a full season, raising concerns about their ability to recognize his value sooner. After all, Holiday’s reputation as a dedicated team player willing to do whatever it takes to win is well-established within the league.

Here’s where I offer a different perspective on the timing of this extension: Wyc and the Celtics management want every member of that locker room to recognize Jrue Holiday as an integral part of the team’s future. When Holiday speaks during playoff huddles, his teammates need to know that they’re hearing from someone who embodies the pure, unadulterated spirit of a Celtic. With a roster brimming with NBA all-star talent, whose voice will rise above the rest when challenges arise?

Jayson Tatum, their best player, may not be the vocal leader this team needs. Al Horford, the veteran presence, might not always be on the court during crucial moments of close games. While Derek White and Kristaps Porzingis are invaluable assets, they might not be the go-to figures to lead the team to victory in crunch time. This leaves Jrue Holiday and Jaylen Brown as the remaining contenders for that role.

Brown, with his record-breaking 5-year/$304 million contract kicking in next year, carries a history of underperformance in high-pressure games. Referencing Tuesday night’s loss to Milwaukee, where he shot inefficiently and accumulated turnovers, along with Game 7 against Miami last year, paints a picture of inconsistency. In contrast, Holiday brings championship experience and the respect of his peers when crucial decisions need to be made during pivotal moments.

By offering Holiday this contract extension now, the Celtics front office sends a clear message: Jrue Holiday is the player they trust to lead this team through the playoffs with authority and the backing of his teammates. They want him to be the decision-maker in critical situations because that’s what the fans crave, and it’s precisely what the executives envision for their franchise. This extension isn’t just about finances; it’s about establishing a culture and setting expectations as they embark on their playoff journey together.